Evolution of Industrial Policy
-
Nehruvian socialism: In 1954, Parliament adopted resolution to establish ‘Socialistic Pattern of Society’ where a larger share of production activity is brought under the public sector.
-
Hard socialism of Indira Gandhi: Went on to nationalise all major banks, entire insurance sector, all coal mines, and some of the larger enterprises in oil refining, steel, copper and textile sectors.
-
New Industrial Policy, 1991: Ended public sector monopoly in all sectors except railways and atomic energy. Yet, the practice of adding more public sector enterprises continued.
-
Financial investment in public enterprises progressively actually went up from Rs 2.3 trillion in 1998 to Rs 9.9 trillion in 2014 and touching Rs 16.4 trillion in 2019.
-
Significance of the Strategic Disinvestment Policy (SDP) 2021: As discussed under the Budget 2021-22 –
-
Seek to reverse the history of socialism: By putting two nationalised banks and an insurance company on the privatisation list, for the first time, it strikes at the heart of Indira Gandhi-era nationalisations.
-
The new approach: Proposes to privatise all CPSEs in all sectors other than four. Even in these SDP 2021 promises to limit the presence of CPSEs to a ‘bare minimum’, leading to future privatisation:
-
Atomic energy, space and defence.
-
Transport and telecommunications.
-
Power, petroleum, coal and minerals.
-
Banking, insurance and financial services.
-
-
Sector-wise exit plan:
-
If SDP were implemented in earnest, the government would exit the agricultural sector entirely.
-
In industry, it would quit manufacturing steel, chemicals and pharmaceuticals, engineering goods, transportation vehicles and equipment, industrial and consumer goods and textiles.
-
In services, the exit list would include trading and marketing, consultancy services of various kinds, and hotels and tourism.
-
Way forward
-
Disallow allocations of taxpayer money to CPSEs: Units needing financial resources for restructuring or other purposes must be required to raise them in the market at commercial terms.
-
The policy should be to hive off excess land and auction it for housing or other productive use.
-
-
Appoint a separate ministry of privatisation: As implementation of SDP 2021 is a complex long-term project and the Department of Investment and Public Asset Management (DIPAM) is not up to the task.
-
It has not been able to privatise even listed CPSEs in which the government stake is less than 60%.
-